Northumberland Conservative councillor Guy Renner-Thompson is demanding answers from the Labour Government following revelations about the financial collapse of Merit, the contractor responsible for building Berwick’s £35 million hospital.
Official documents published by administrators Interpath on 23 December 2025 reveal that Merit was struggling with delays to major projects and disputes over contract variations with key customers.
The report confirms that attempts to settle a dispute with a major customer in September 2025 failed. It also reveals that HM Revenue & Customs presented a winding-up petition against Merit on 29 August 2025, damaging the company’s ability to secure new business.
Separately, Merit publicly warned on 2 September 2025 that a key customer owed it substantial payments which were significantly overdue. At the time, Merit was delivering major NHS projects, including Berwick Community Hospital and the Seaton Delaval Medicines Manufacturing Centre.
Although the administrators do not identify the customer was involved in the failed negotiations, Northumbria NHS Trust was Merit’s only large customer at the time. The findings raise questions about whether public bodies played any part in the events leading to Merit’s collapse.
Cllr Renner-Thompson said, “These are extraordinary revelations. We now know from the administrators that Merit was struggling to resolve a major contractual dispute while HMRC was pursuing it through the courts.
“Merit had also publicly warned that a key customer owed it substantial sums of money.
“Was one arm of the state disputing or withholding payments while another was pursuing the company with a winding-up petition? We don’t yet know for sure whether the NHS was the customer involved. But if it was, what did ministers know, and what action did they take?
“Two months later, Merit collapsed, 284 people were made redundant and Berwick was left with an unfinished hospital.”
Notes
- Administrators’ report: Interpath’s proposals for Merit Group Services Ltd, dated 23 December 2025, confirm unsuccessful negotiations with an unnamed key customer, contract variation disputes, HMRC’s winding-up petition and 284 redundancies.
- Overdue payments: Merit publicly disclosed substantial overdue payments from a key customer, reported by Construction Enquirer on 2 September 2025.
- Hospital progress: Northumberland County Council Health and Wellbeing Overview and Scrutiny Committee minutes, 11 November 2025.
- Remedial works: Northumbria Healthcare announcement, 12 October 2026, confirming extensive replacement works and a target of substantial construction completion by summer 2028.
Sources:
Administrators’ filings — Companies House
Merit’s overdue payments — Construction Enquirer
The revelations come as Northumbria Healthcare has announced that substantial sections of Berwick’s unfinished hospital must be removed and replaced.
In November 2025, senior NHS representatives told Northumberland County Council’s Health and Wellbeing Overview and Scrutiny Committee that excellent progress had been made and the overall building work was complete.
Yet less than a year later, the Trust has confirmed that major mechanical and electrical installations, internal walls and sections of the external façade must be removed. Construction is now expected to continue until summer 2028, with the additional cost to taxpayers still unknown.
Cllr Renner-Thompson added: “How did we go from being told that excellent progress had been made to discovering that so much of the hospital needs ripping out?
“Was the work defective from the outset, or was some of it allowed to deteriorate after Merit collapsed? Was the building properly protected from the weather? Are taxpayers now paying millions to replace defective work, or work that could have been saved?
“Northumbria Healthcare must publish the technical reports explaining what went wrong and when the problems were first identified.”
Cllr Renner-Thompson has also called on North Northumberland MP David Smith and Cramlington and Killingworth MP Emma Foody to explain what they knew about Merit’s difficulties.
“David Smith represents the people waiting for Berwick’s new hospital. Emma Foody represents the constituency where Merit was based and hundreds of jobs were lost.
“Did they know about the company’s financial difficulties, the payment dispute or HMRC’s action? What representations did they make to ministers? We need to establish the full facts.
“I’m joining Cllr Georgina Hill in calling for an independent investigation into Merit’s collapse, the disputed payments, HMRC’s actions and the management of the hospital project.
“Hundreds of jobs have gone, Berwick faces years of further delays, and taxpayers could be facing a huge additional bill. If the actions of public bodies contributed to this disaster, the public has a right to know.”
Councillor Renner-Thompson told The Bridge:
‘My involvement is as a senior Northumberland County Councillor. Although the hospital is in Berwick, my residents in Belford, Bamburgh, Seahouses and the surrounding villages rely on it too. It’s an important facility for the whole of North Northumberland.
‘The hospital is an NHS project, not a County Council one. When the Trust has previously reported to the Council, we have been assured that everything was progressing to plan. However, the Council has no direct oversight of the project or powers over the NHS, so we have largely had to rely on what the Trust has told us.
‘Interestingly, the Council’s own appraisal back in 2018 raised concerns about the costs and risks of developing the existing site when we were looking at a joint project with the leisure centre.
‘As for alternative locations, that is entirely a matter for the NHS Trust, not the County Council. NCC is not responsible for choosing the site, funding or delivering the hospital. Any decision to reconsider the location, including assessing offers of alternative land, would have to be taken by the NHS.

I was interested to read the comments from County Councillor Renner Thompson. I believe the problems with this disastrous project go much further back than the demise of Merit. The choice of site being a major factor. The planning process around this should be part of any investigation and not solely focused on the procurement of Merit. Damon Kent Executive Director of Estates and Facilities addressed resident issues i.e. concerns and complaints as “more to do with planning,” this would be in the remit of Northumberland County Council. Merit had stated that construction delays were included in the reasons for their going into liquidation and this project could certainly fall into that category. This is not in any way to excuse Merit, their methods and the quality of the build which we had reported in the past to NHS Northumbria during our meetings with Trust members.
The site is unsuitable. It has been admitted that because it is constricted materials could not flow on as required. In addition it has been stated many times that the restricted access roads are unsuitable, a major problem which had caused delays in getting units etc to the site. Also the entry/exit points are hazardous via a congested, at times, Primary School. Also a blind corner out of Brucegate onto a blind junction at Scott’s Place
The first site that was earmarked for the hospital was at the top of Sunnyside Hill, with good access to the bypass, now the housing estate Barley Rise. The first NHS project manager, Rob Sanderson told me that this was the “best site”. To date, as the closest residents to the current site and most affected we have had contact with 5 project managers. A second site, that was the majority choice of a packed public meeting in the Town Hall was Seton Hall, later dismissed as unsuitable because of “contamination issues,” now apparently suitable for another housing estate Seton Gardens. There have been other site options made available with direct access to the bypass, one of which was Bill Flannigan’s land adjacent to Etal Road.
It is stated that the people of Berwick voted for the current 19th century site. This is unsuitable for a 21st century hospital. I find it difficult to find anyone who voted for this. Who organised the vote? What method of vote casting was used? What percentage of the population responded.
Finally NHS Northumbria stated themselves that the site was unsuitable, which taking everything into account is proving patently obvious.
Thanks Tom
There’s a full update in the next Bridge. Including a first-hand account of the unfolding building disaster. Make sure you buy a few copies!
Wendy, Editor
For sure Wendy.
Tom
On reflection I would like to add further comment to County Councillor Renner-Thomson’s statement to The Bridge where he says “ the Council has no direct oversight of the project or powers over the NHS”.
As the Local Planning Authority were part of the decision making process where this project could be sited they agreed that this constricted, sensitive Conservation Area, together with all the inherent access problems was suitable. This was absolutely within their control.
In addition numerous Variations of Conditions have been passed by NCC Planning throughout the construction period that have considerably altered the structure from the original plans, which many judged as entirely unsuitable in the first place within this sensitive conservation area.
Also people would expect that it would be the responsibility of Northumberland County Council to ensure enviromental protection throughout the project.
Tom Young